Key Environmental Needs

X. Financing environmental improvements

The State Fund for Environmental Protection

99. Some of the CEE countries have developed fairly extensive systems for financing environmental improvements, while others are still in the early stages of devising such mechanisms. State Funds for Environmental Protection have been organized in some CEE countries to provide grants and soft loans for environmental investments. The financial resources for these Funds are usually collected through discharge fees and non-compliance fines imposed on polluters. Governmental subsidies, various environmental taxes, interest from the loans, etc., add additional money to the State Funds. There is widespread support to organize State Funds for Environmental Protection in the CEE countries that have not yet established them.

100. The special arrangements made to establish State Funds for Environmental Protection illustrate the urgent need for a stable flow of funds for environmental protection measures. However, it also demonstrates a lack of integrity in the overall economic and environmental programs. Funds earmarked for environmental protection are excluded from any use except direct environmental improvements. Thus, direct environmental investments are considered a higher priority than sustainable investments which satisfy and integrate vital economic and environmental needs simultaneously.

101. The separate financial system which provides funds for environmental improvements is a consequence of the segregated approach to economic and environmental considerations. As the idea of sustainable development is still in its initial phase, a special system for funding priority environmental projects is justified, and will continue to play an important role in the CEE countries during the transition period.

102. Procedures for disbursing and replenishing environmental funds need to be improved. Priorities should be based on an established environmental policy, but realistic and balanced environmental policies remain pending in most of the CEE countries. The management of State Environmental Funds also requires improvement. Professional, financial management backed by an in-depth understanding of environmental problems are the most frequently mentioned needs in this regard. A stable staff and transparent procedures for the operation of the State Funds are highly recommended by experts, as well.

Economic instruments

103. Environmental protection is supported not only by subsidies provided by the State Fund, but also by incentives created by economic instruments. These instruments can generate payments which redirect funds to environmental protection. The potential fund-raising role of economic instruments is, however, hindered in some CEE countries due to high inflation and the bankruptcy of the largest polluters.

104. Economic instruments are also seen as a tool for motivating companies to reduce pollution. In the CEE, however, environmental charges and non-compliance fees are often ineffective as incentives to reduce pollution because it is usually cheaper for polluters to simply pay the fines than to implement abatement measures. The bigger the savings from not treating waste, the lower the incentive role economic instruments play. Experts assess that charges imposed for pollution discharges in the CEE countries are many times lower than the waste purification costs. Thus, there is little incentive to reduce pollution from a company's financial point of view.

A prospective environmental financing system

105. The role of public spending for environmental protection will remain decisive in the transition period. While market forces are playing a growing role in encouraging environmental investments in the private sector, governments will continue to provide the majority of funds for necessary environmental improvements for some time to come. There is still a large state-owned sector of the economy that requires environmental subsidies. The state must also provide funds for local and regional governments to meet their environmental requirements.

106. The general concept of funding environmental protection needs to be changed in the CEE countries. Environmental protection measures should be paid for by those who benefit from using the environment for their business purposes. Users of the environment must be more involved in and responsible for solving local environmental problems. Communities should also be prepared to provide funds for environmental protection activities.

107. The "polluter pays" principle must be fully adopted and enforced in the CEE countries. Income generated at the expense of the environment should be reverted to restore the damage. The polluter pays principle should improve the impact of economic instruments on investors' decisions. It should also allow for profitable production, while eliminating negative environmental consequences of that production.


REC * PUBLICATIONS * STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUES 1 * KEY ENVIRONMENTAL NEEDS

PREVIOUS NEXT COVER PAGE HOME PAGE