Croatia



Introduction

  Since the late 1980s, public interest and citizen involvement concerning environmental issues in Croatia has increased. Environmental NGOs typically identify problems, research needs, seek solutions on both local and global levels, and motivate citizens to get involved. However, such good intentions by citizens could yield better results if Croatia had a long-term national strategy on environmental protection and a policy and organizational framework that specified working relationships between the government and the non-profit sector.

  The first initiatives in environmental protection emerged at the beginning of this century through actions aimed at protecting Croatia's natural and cultural heritage. The result of these activities was the establishment of Croatia's first national parks, Velebit and Plitvice Lakes, in 1928. The Croatian Society of Natural Sciences began with the magazine Nature as early as 1911. And the Croatian Ecological Society has been popularizing environmental issues since 1969.

  During the 1970s and 1980s, many new environmental groups emerged that consisted largely of scientists and experts. More pronounced activism was brought about by the Section for Environmental Protection of the Socialist Union of Workers. Although politically controlled, the Section did have some measure of success gathering and utilizing experts and raising public awareness. In the last few years, many organizations have been founded by concerned citizens, some of which believed in the need for an umbrella organization. This led to the establishment of the Croatian Green Alliance in 1990, an organization that represented most environmental NGOs at that time and now has grown to represent about 60 NGOs.

According to the Regional Environmental Center's NGO Directory, there are more than 180 environmental groups operating in Croatia; one-third of them are located in Zagreb and most of the newer ones are located in smaller towns and villages. According to the NGO Directory, NGOs are active in 74 different locations throughout Croatia. In Zagreb, there are several advanced groups such as Green Action Zagreb and Svanimir. More than twenty organizations, such as the Society for the Protection of Waters and Seas and the Society for Soil Studies, are professional NGOs. These organizations are located in Zagreb, though they have members across the country, and deal mainly with pollution-related issues. It is also important to mention the Croatian Green Alliance, which has brought together ecological organizations, professional societies and other nonpolitical organizations with ecological programs that are active in the Republic of Croatia. According to its statute the Alliance supports and coordinates member activities, and stimulates the establishment of new organizations. Unfortunately, because of unstable financial conditions, the Alliance does not have professional personnel working full time or permanent facilities. Regardless, the Alliance creates a basic network for a significant number of NGOs. Several organizations, such as Lijepa Nasa and Young Nature Keepers - Croatian Society of Natural Sciences, have branches across the country but are more or less centralized. Other organizations, like the Croatian Mountaineering Association and the Scout Association of Croatia, include environmental protection themes in their activities.

  Nongovernmental organizations still register according to the Law on Citizen's Associations and Social Organizations that was passed in 1982. It has been amended and changed several times over the years, with the latest version dating from 1990. The Ministry of Public Administration is responsible for developing the new Law on Associations, but this much-needed legislation is still unavailable. The public had an opportunity to comment on the draft version of the law, and criticism was voiced on everything from the general framework to specific provisions and acts. NGOs from different fields tried to influence the development of legislation that would define their future, the most notable work having been done by The Center for Development of Nonprofit Organizations (CERANEO). Critics concluded that the law was not drawn up properly, and that similar laws in developed countries were not used as benchmarks.

  One of the most crucial issues for the development and existence of the non-profit sector is the question of tax deductions. Unfortunately, existing tax regulations do not grant tax relief to NGOs (except those associated with cultural activities), a situation that differs from most other CEE countries in transition. The general opinion of the current government is that funds should be collected and distributed by the state: a former minister of finance publicly labeled tax deductions as a money laundering device.

  The Law on Environmental Protection (1994) is a base regulation for strategic documents such as the national strategy, programs and reports on the state of the environment. This law also relates to future regulations that would create a legislative base for increased public involvement in environmental affairs. According to certain existing regulations, the public is supposed to be involved in some decisionmaking processes, such as plan and program development. For example, as a result of public debate on the Zagreb municipal incinerator and the efforts of Green Action, the project was postponed until all the issues revolving around waste management had been addressed and solved. When the REC published its Manual for Public Participation in the Croatian language, the response was enormously positive, not only among green NGOs and individuals, but also among governmental institutions and NGOs working in other fields.

  Currently, there is no legislative support for obligatory cooperation between governmental and nongovernmental organizations, or for the participation of NGOs in the decisionmaking process. There is some cooperation in the environmental sphere, but it has not been institutionalized and is limited to individual cases. Where it does exist, cooperation usually takes place with the State Directorate for Environment. Significant documents are presented and discussed by experts and NGOs, and special teams are organized when NGOs are able to participate in the preparation and development of major documents. The State Directorate for Environment cooperates with NGOs on certain projects, such as Earth Day celebrations and the publication of books (Agenda 21, Two Minutes for Green Planet, War Destruction in Croatia), and provides support in the form of expertise and finances.

Results of the Mail Questionnaires

  As part of the NGO Needs Assessment Project, mail questionnaires were sent to 187 environmental NGOs in Croatia; of that number, 107 questionnaires (57 percent) were completed and returned.

Organizational Characteristics

  According to the survey results, 27 percent of the organizations that responded have more than 100 members, and 37 percent have around twenty members. It is interesting to note that 62 percent of the NGOs were active before 1990, and that the largest proportion of new NGOs was formed between 1994 and 1995. This growth corresponds to the commencement of activities at the REC Local Office in Zagreb. Almost all of the NGOs are officially registered, and many of them (34 percent) are focused strictly on activities in the environmental field, while the others are involved in other activities as well. The majority of the NGOs that were surveyed (65 percent) are active on the local and regional level, one-third (34 percent) are active on the national level, and only a few (2.8 percent) participate at the international level. Half of Croatian NGOs require membership fees. More than half (56 percent) do not have their own office space, but it came as a pleasant surprise that 22 percent have own their own offices and that 19 percent regularly rent working space. On the other hand, the fact that 87 percent do not have paid personnel is not encouraging. The supply of technical equipment seems to be satisfactory; however, NGOs may not own the bulk of this equipment, but rather they may only have access to it. While many have telephones, typewriters, fax machines and personal computers, more than half do not have e-mail, televisions or video recorders. English, German and Italian are the most common foreign languages.

Activities

  Most NGOs (99 percent) are involved with education and training, followed by information gathering (98 percent) and fieldwork (90 percent); about half (49 percent) maintained they do not use protest actions or engage in research and technology-related activities (53 percent). Quite a few NGOs (51 percent) occasionally use the results of studies on environmental impact assessments. NGOs also recognized lobbying and participating in the process of developing legislation (59 percent) and networking with other NGOs (65 percent) as important strategies.

Success

  Most NGOs evaluate themselves as successful, either partially (46 percent) or completely (25 percent). According to these figures, most NGOs appear to be satisfied with their work.

Financial Status

  No organization labeled their financial position as very good; in fact, 38 percent described their financial situation as poor and 17 percent as very poor. Eleven organizations estimated their annual budgets to be over USD 50,000, four NGOs placed themselves in the USD 50,000 to USD 100,000 range, and three groups have budgets larger than USD 100,000.

  It is interesting to note that 54 percent of the respondents receive their financial support from national private donations or from domestic foundations. Because domestic environmental foundations do not exist, it is possible to conclude that NGOs think of financial support as distinct from activities of their members or supporters. Furthermore, for 68 percent of the surveyed NGOs, international foundations are not a source of financing. Thirteen percent admitted that foreign and international support contributes between 25 percent and 50 percent of their budgets, and the REC partially finances 53 percent of Croatian NGOs. Not surprisingly, every Croatian NGO believes that external support is either of the utmost importance (39 percent) or is somewhat important (61 percent).

Needs and Problems

  The following is a ranking of Croatian NGOs' most significant needs and problems: insufficient funding, limited access to modern means of communication (telephone, fax, e-mail), insufficient environmental training, the general weakness of the environmental movement in Croatia, a lack of cooperation with other environmental organizations, and lack of volunteer support.

Cooperation

  Internal cooperation does exist in Croatia, and it is much stronger than external cooperation with NGOs from other countries. Only six percent of NGOs do not have any cooperation with local and regional organizations. Most of this cooperation is based on personal contacts (39 percent), while a significant share takes place via information exchange (28 percent) and joint projects (26 percent). Lack of cooperation at the national level was noted by 12 percent of the NGOs; nationwide cooperation can be attributed largely to information exchange (41 percent) and personal contacts (32 percent).

  Almost half of NGOs (48 percent) do not have any contacts with NGOs from other countries. What cooperation does exist is based largely on information exchange or personal contacts, and to a smaller extent on conducting joint projects. Relationships with governments, both at the national and local levels, are rare. Cooperation with local governments is much better: only 15 percent of NGOs do not cooperate with local authorities. Over half of all NGOs (53 percent) do not communicate with the national government. Many NGOs believe that effective cooperation with governments is an important factor for their success, followed by cooperation among Croatian, international and Western NGOs.


Search the NGO Directory Database.


REC * PUBLICATIONS * NGO DIRECTORY * CROATIA * OVERVIEW

PREVIOUS NEXT COVER PAGE HOME PAGE