HomeAbout the RECSearchSite MapContact Us
REC Home PageREC ProgrammesSustainable cities

 

Stockholm Environment Institute, Projects
- Multi-city Study on Household Environmental Problems in Third World Countries

 

Multi-city Study on Household Environmental Problems in Third World Countries
Beijing Environmental Master Planning

Capacity 21- Capacity Building for the Implementation of Agenda 21 in Estonia
The Baltic Palette
Ulysses - Urban lifestyles, Sustainability and Integrated Environmental Assessment

Lead Researcher: Gordon McGranahan, Marianne Kjellen
Region: 4 Cities - Accra (Ghana), Port Elizabeth (South Africa), Jakarta (Malaysia), Sao Paolo (Brazil)

Overview

The Stockholm Environment Institute initiated a program on urban environments in 1991, focusing first on the problems arising at the household and neighbourhood levels. Especially in poor neighbourhoods in Third World cities, complex sets of interrelated environmental hazards contribute to the high prevalence of respiratory, diarrhea and vector borne diseases. From a health perspective, these localized urban problems are among the most serious environmental problems in the world. One of the main outcomes of this work in the South demonstrates that 'sustainability' concepts tend to overlook environmental problems of the poor. This research is elaborated in the following reference:

Kjellén, M. and McGranahan, G. (1997) Urban Water - Towards Health and Sustainability. Comprehensive Assessment of the Freshwater Resources of the World. Stockholm Environment Institute (Stockholm), or more generally (and academically) in McGranahan, G., Songsore, J. and Kjellén, M. (1996) Sustainability, poverty and urban environmental transitions. In: Pugh C., (ed.). Sustainability, the Environment and Urbanization. London, Earthscan. p103-133.)

As a first step, a comparative study was carried out in collaboration with local research institutions in the mega-cities of São Paulo and Jakarta, and the comparatively smaller city of Accra. The goal was threefold; to support local environmental management efforts; to develop methods applicable to other cities; and to inform international discussions on urban environmental issues.

In response to the lack of relevant information, surveys of about one thousand households, and physical tests of air and/or water quality in a subset of two hundred households, were under-taken in each city. The surveys covered water, sanitation, indoor air pollution, solid waste collection, food handling, pests and crowding. Each major problem area was assessed in terms of the physical processes and severity, the health risks involved, and the priorities of the residents.

Simultaneously, the results indicate that many factors other than poverty are involved, and that the most prominent environmental problems are not always the most important. In Accra, for example, access to water and sanitation facilities is probably more critical to people's health than the quality of the water obtained or the design of the toilets, which is itself more critical than the pollution of the waterways. Local residents may be aware of their particular environmental priorities, but policy discussions tend to centre on the more visible and measurable problems. It is important both to provide better information on local environmental conditions, and to ensure that local priorities are taken seriously.

The fourth study in Port Elizabeth (South Africa) builds on the approach taken in the other three cities. It aims to undertake environmental research in order to inform policy development both locally and internationally.

The main objectives of the study were to:

  • Describe a range of interconnected household environmental problems in Port Elizabeth.
  • Compare the severity of these problems in different socio-economic groups.
  • Evaluate their health impacts.
  • Assess people's priorities regarding improvements.
  • Examine the financial, technological, educational and institutional obstacles to improvements in the context of the results.
  • Draw out some of the policy implications and feed in to ongoing policy processes.

The study focused on the following categories of physical environmental issues:

  • Neighbourhood characteristics
  • Housing quality and crowding
  • Water and sanitation
  • Food contamination
  • Solid waste
  • Pests and pesticides
  • Air pollution

The primary data collection employed household questionnaire surveys, physical tests of air and water quality, interviews with selected government officials and leaders of grass roots organizations, video filmed interviews and home visits, as well as focus group discussions.

Publications: McGranahan, G., Lewin, S., Fransen, T., Hunt, C., Kjellén, M., Pretty, J., Stephens, C., Virgin, I. 1999. Environmental Change and Human Health in Countries of Africa, the Caribbean and the Pacific. Published by SEI and London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. ISBN: 91 88714 69 1
Web site: http://www.sei.se/urbproj1.html

  

  

  Home PageAbout the RECSearchSite MapBack to Top
 
  REC