Significance of environmental and energy taxes in the taxation systems of the EU
The share of taxes in the GDP of the EU increased by more than 8% between 1970 and 1995, and, it represented 41.6% of total EU GDP in 1995. Revenues from environmental taxes represented 0.7% of EU GDP and 1.7% of total tax revenues in EU in 1995. Revenues from taxes on energy in the same year were 2.2% of EU GDP and 5.2% of total tax revenues in EU.
The taxation systems vary between Member States. However, there are some common features. The largest share is raised by labor taxation, which represented 21.5% of total EU GDP in 1995. Increasing taxation of labor plays also a role in the high and persistent unemployment in Europe. This general trend has not changed since the publication of the Commission's White Paper on Growth, Competitiveness and Employment, which recommended a reduction in taxation of labor by 1 or 2% of GDP. In order to progress, some countries want to reduce labor taxation and increase other taxes. The Fifth Environmental Programme "Towards Sustainable Development" follows this idea and calls to increase taxation of environmentally damaging activities and reduce taxation of labor and investments. Experience shows, however, that this recommendation is not easy to implement in practice and effects on unemployment may not be huge.
Eurostat - the statistical office of the EU has published a statistical document entitled "The Structure of the Taxation System in the European Union". The purpose of this publication is to interpret fiscal trends in order to provide a general picture of the evolution of taxation systems in Europe at different levels of aggregation, and, to monitor if and how Member States follow the recommendations of the White Paper.
The publication is divided into four main parts. The summary in Chapter II gives an overview of the evolution of taxation system in the European Union and particular Member States in the period 1970 to 1995. Chapter III focuses on the methodology on which the information and data of the report is based. A country analysis of each Member State is provided in Chapter IV. Four different tables are presented for each country:
- standard split of taxation according to direct, indirect taxes and social contributions;
- a breakdown of taxation according to receiving governmental level;
- a breakdown of taxation according to economic function; and,
- the economic burden of taxation in the form if implicit tax rates.
Chapter V presents the results of the analysis in the form of cross-country tables which allow comparison of data between countries.
The report also covers environmental and energy taxes. According to the applied methodology, environmental taxes aim at integrating external costs, which derive from consumption of the environment, into the private costs of economic agents. They vary from emission or product levies, through certain registration duties to fees. In some cases, the environmental aspect is incorporated to other forms of taxation (e.g. VAT), where it is a part of the discriminatory function of the whole tax, i.e. influencing against the use of such goods or against such activities. Energy taxes are imposed on energy sources (petroleum products, coal, etc.) or on the use of energy.
The overall fiscal importance of environmental taxes is rather low in most Member States. In 1995, revenues from environmental taxes represented 0.7% of EU GDP and 1.7% of total tax revenues in the EU. Only in the Netherlands (5.8% of total taxation) and in Denmark (4.3% of total taxation) environmental taxes are on larger scale, in both cases as a result of comparatively high taxes on the use of cars.
The taxation of energy has only slightly increased since 1970. In 1995, revenues from taxes on energy were 2.2% of EU GDP and 5.2% of total tax revenues in EU. Countries with comparatively high share of energy taxes in total taxation are Portugal (8.4%), Italy (7.7%) and Luxembourg (7.0%). The most important energy taxes are excise duties on mineral oils.
Some more detailed information from the report on environmental and energy taxes in EU countries are presented in the supplement at the end of this newsletter.
Eurostat (1997): Structures of the Taxation System in the European Union, 1970-95. Statistical Document of the Eurostat. 111pp. price excluding VAT ECU 10. To order contact: Office for Official Publications of the European Communities in Luxembourg or country sales offices. Additional information is available on http:/europa.eu.int
Environmental Taxes in the European Union, 1995

The following instruments are included in the data shown in the table:
Environmental taxes:
- Netherlands: motor vehicle duty paid by households and enterprises; levy on water pollution from households and enterprises; vehicle registration fees from households and enterprises; waste disposal charges from households and enterprises; sewerage charges from households and enterprises; special tax on motor cars; taxes on discharge of waste to public waters / air pollution / noise; fuel tax payable under the Environmental Protection Act; local tax for roads, local amenities and sewerage services; other environmental taxes.
- Denmark: motor vehicle weight duty from households and producers; motor vehicle and aircraft registration duty; large yachts registration tax; duties on sulfur / electric bulbs and fuses/ chlorinated solvents / tires / rechargeable NiCd batteries / piped water / certain retail containers / carrier bags / waste / CFC / extraction and import of raw materials / disposable tableware / insecticides, herbicides etc.
- Ireland: motor vehicle duties by households and enterprises; fees under the petroleum and minerals development; duty on table water; excise duties on motor vehicles incl. motorcycles.
- Spain: miscellaneous and fines; municipal road tax paid by enterprises.
- Austria: tax on motor vehicles paid by households; duty on fertilizers; duty on vehicles based on fuel consumption.
- UK: motor vehicle duty paid by households and enterprises; car tax.
- Germany: tax on motor vehicles paid by households and enterprises; excise duties on lamps; administrative charges.
- Greece: tax on electricity, communication and transport services; car registration fee; motor vehicle duty; fines and surcharges on indirect taxes.
- France: motor vehicle duties paid by households and enterprises; domestic refuse removal rate; metered water consumption charge; mining duties; vehicle registration certificate; levy for 'agences financières de bassin'; special tax on certain road vehicles.
- Italy: motor vehicle duties paid by households and firms; special duty on table waters.
- Belgium: motor vehicle duties paid by households and enterprises; registration tax; road fund tax paid by households; environmental taxes.
- Sweden: sales tax on motor vehicles; special tax against acidification; forestry levy; tax on motor vehicles.
- Luxembourg: motor vehicle duties paid by households and enterprises.
- Portugal: taxes on vehicles paid by households and companies; road taxes - compensation; price differentials on town gas; road taxes - traffic/haulage; tax on sand extraction licenses; tax on motor vehicles sales.
- Finland: tax on motor vehicles paid by households and enterprises; oil damage levy; oil waste levy.
Taxes on Energy in the European Union, 1995

The following instruments are included in the data shown in the table:
Taxes on Energy:
- Netherlands: duty on petrol / mineral oil, tax on petroleum stocks;
- Denmark: duty on petrol / electricity / certain oil products / coal / gas / carbon dioxide.
- Ireland: duties on mineral hydrocarbon light oil and other sorts of oil;
- Spain: other taxes on imported hydrocarbons; special taxes on hydrocarbons.
- Austria: duty on hydrocarbon oils; federal and special taxes on mineral oils.
- UK: duty on hydrocarbon oils; gas levy paid by British Gas; non-fossil fuel obligation levy.
- Germany: tax on mineral oils; special levies.
- Greece: tax on petroleum, petroleum products, lubricants and gas.
- France: inland duty on petroleum products; electricity meter charge.
- Italy: excise duty on mineral oils / liquefied petroleum gases / methane / electricity; in-bond surcharges on mineral oils / liquefied petroleum gases; surcharge on electricity duty changed to the ENEL.
- Belgium: excise duty on mineral oils; energy contribution.
- Sweden: taxes on petrol and fuel; tax on energy consumption; special tax on electric power from nuclear station; taxes on electricity from certain sources; tax on nuclear fuel.
- Luxembourg: excise duty on mineral oils; special excise duties on certain mineral oils.
- Portugal: price differentials on LPG and petroleum products; supplementary state revenue on production and distribution of electrical energy; energy services.
- Finland: excise duties on liquid fuels / electricity; stock building levies on liquid fuels.
Source: Eurostat (1997): Structures of the Taxation Systems in the European Union 1970-95. European Communities, Brussels.
REC * PROGRAMS * SOFIA INITIATIVES * ECONOMIC INSTRUMENTS * GREEN BUDGET * JUNE 23, 1998